Prime Day smackdown: $25 Echo Dot vs. $25 Google Home Mini

amazon-echo-dot-vs-google-home-mini

$25 buys you one of these. Which one should you choose?


Amazon and Google

It’s not even Prime Day yet (that happens Monday, as you’ve undoubtedly heard), but two of the biggest rivals in smart-home technology are already on sale — at prices that match their all-time lows and probably won’t be seen again until Black Friday. The question: If you’ve got some spare cash to spend on a smart speaker, which one should you get?

First, the contenders. Amazon already has a handful of pre-Prime Day deals up and running, including the Echo Dot (3rd-generation) for $24.99.

Meanwhile, Walmart has a whole bunch of Google Home and Nest products on sale, including the Google Home Mini for $25.

These two hockey pucks normally sell for $50, so they’re both 50% off — making this a win-win scenario in my book. That said, if you don’t already have a smart speaker (and you’re not freaked out by the idea that humans might be listening to your queries), is there a clear winner between these two?

Here’s my take: If you own an Android phone, meaning you’re already acquainted with and accustomed to “OK Google”-ing, the Google Home Mini will fit your lifestyle better than an Echo Dot. The former is also the better-sounding of the two, at least according to CNET’s Google Home Mini review.

However, the Echo Dot is probably the more versatile of the two products, with a larger selection of skills and compatible voice-controlled devices. It also has more intuitive touch controls and a line-out jack for connecting external speakers. On the other hand, it’s the more reserved-looking of the two, with rather drab black, white and gray color choices. The Mini, at least, has a few pastels on the menu. Read CNET’s Echo Dot review to learn more.

Whichever model you choose, you’ll probably want to add an external speaker. (Both support Bluetooth connectivity.) Because while they may sound good enough for your den or nightstand, let’s be honest: These are small speakers. For big sound, you’ll need to help them out. These are our picks for the best Bluetooth speakers of 2019.

What do you think? If I handed you $25 right now, which smart speaker would you buy — and why?


Now playing:
Watch this:

How to decide on a smart speaker



1:08


CNET’s Cheapskate scours the web for great deals on PCs, phones, gadgets and much more. Note that CNET may get a share of revenue from the sale of the products featured on this page. Questions about the Cheapskate blog? Find the answers on our FAQ page. Find more great buys on the CNET Deals page and follow the Cheapskate on Facebook and Twitter!

$24

CNET may get a commission from retail offers.

Kya Gin Wong
Rex is Editor-in-Chief of TheTechyTrends and was previously Editor-in-Chief of GamerLive and China Watch Online. Rex has a real passion for gadgets, mobile, technology and business.

Popular Reads